원정 개요

Singha Roy, Biswas and Pemba left C4 at 10 pm on 19 April for summit. They arrived at 10 am on 20 April, stayed on summit for 10 minutes and returned to C4 at 3 pm. Next day on 21 April they spent the night at C2. On 22 April they descended to BC. Summit day weather was good. Chinese climbers Yang, Rao and their Sherpa were ahead of Singha Roy team. The American woman with Sherpas were behind the Indian team.

Sherpa:
Pemba Chhuti Sherpa, 15/07/73, Yaphu-9, Makalu, Everest X5, Makalu X1


Note: Several photos and comments have surfaced that give doubts to the status of all the summiters on 20 April 2012 for Annapurna I.

One set of photos show the Indian team of Debasish Biswas and Basanta Singha Roy standing 50-60m below the top of the summit ridge with a climber dressed in red climbing towards the summit ridge high in the background.

Another set of photos show the Chinese team of Yang Chun-Feng and Rao Jian-Feng (dressed in red) near the crest of the summit ridge. One Chinese and two Sherpas are shown on top of the crest and one Chinese and one Sherpa are shown as stopping below the crest. It also appears that the Chinese team did not proceed along the crest of the summit ridge to the true summit that is 20-50m further away in an upwardly horizontal direction.

The widow of Rao states that her husband told her that Rao summited, but not Yang. Both Rao and Yao were killed in June 2013 when the base camp at Nanga Parbat was attacked by terrorists.

Other comments put the American team of Cleo Weidlich and her Sherpa either above or below the Indian team, but not at the summit ridge.

For the above reasons, these ascents are being marked as “disputed.”